Microsoft recently released a major update to their Windows Media Player bringing it up to version 11. Also announced was the launch of a new online music service called Urge from MTV. Urge means nothing to me because it’s not available in New Zealand, just like most other online music services (there’s also no iTunes here.)
The interface looks really good, and has a definite Vista feel about it. Navigating around the library is a bit tricky at first because there is no tree interface like there was in WMP10. Navigation is provided by drop down menus which appear by clicking on the level above where you want to go. This is the same navigational method that Vista uses in Windows Explorer and I don’t like it there either – it takes a lot of clicks to get anywhere.
Once you’re in the library you can see that WMP11 places a huge focus on browsing albums and artists by visually looking through the album art pictures. This works well if all your albums have album art but if they don’t it gets a bit confusing as all albums have the same grey cover.
I’m not normally a Windows Media Player user because I’ve been using iTunes for the last year or so after purchasing my first iPod. One of the things I initially liked about WMP over iTunes was the way it could sort out my media library, rename all the files correctly, and download the album art from the internet automatically. The biggest problem with this is that it would sometimes get it wrong and rename all the songs of a particular album completely out of order. And once it got into this state, it was almost impossible to rename them as they should.
This new version of WMP suffers from the same problem – if the feature works, it works well… but if it gets it wrong it causes you all sorts of issues. Some albums work well – the songs get updated perfectly and the album art is downloaded and everything is great. But then you run into issues like this, for example.

As you can see in the image, the first track of the 50 Cent album hasn’t been picked up by the online service, and shows up as a single track on it’s own album. Even though the album name is the same as the correct one and everything else matches up, it appears to be impossible to move this track into the correct album. Drag and drop doesn’t work and there’s also no way to manually fix it up.
These issues ruin the experience for me and I would rather spend the extra time managing my music manually with iTunes than have to put up with the software messing things up for me.